Instinct by Matthew Mello

Instinct
By
Matthew Mello
__________________

Effect: This is Matthew's (safe) approach to the spike under cup version of the classic russian roulette routine. A nail is placed under 1 of 4 cups. The cups are then freely mixed by the spectator with the magicians back turned. After concentration the magician then crushes each and every cup, only leaving 1. The cup containing the nail.

Download: I have wanted this effect for quite a while. However, it wasn't on the top of my list of needed items/effects so I didn't want to buy it plus pay shipping, etc. etc. Recently with the launch of www.thementalplayground.com I heard that it was going to be offered as a download, to which I was elated. I quickly purchased it just after Christmas.

Now, here is where it gets good. I was immediately sent the download link and attempted to download the file. However, not only did it download insanely fast (a bad sign for a large file) but would not play any audio or video. Just a black screen. I shot an e-mail to Brian Rodgers at Mental Playground and we began troubleshooting. Brian worked very hard trying to fix the file but attempt after attempt proved to no avail, it would glitch every time. Not only did Brian offer to refund my money and still give me the product, he was going to ship me a DVD free of charge. Thankfully, however, the download got straightened out and I was able to successfully get the effect. I have never had a magic company not only work as hard as they did to fix the issue but also work as closely with the customer as he did. I was talking to him through personal e-mail at all times day and night. Excellent customer service.


Quality: The video is very good quality and everything is quite clear. I believe this was shot before the "HD era" really came into effect, so it's not modern quality but still very clear. The only issue I actually found was that they used a stark white background with white cups, so sometimes they can be a bit odd to look at. Nothing that hinders learning, just something to point out.

Performances: Thank god, live performances on a DVD... This is a dying trend. Usually the effect is either performed for just the camera or for spectators brought in to film the project. However, Instinct features 3 live performances showing different situations and presentations for the effect. 1 of these is shot in a local magic shop, the other is shot on the street, and the final is filmed in a loud bar, showing how well the effect can carry in noisy situations.

Method: This method is sheer genius. Whatever you are thinking for methodology, you are wrong. There is no marking, switching, forcing, glimpsing, odd ways of mixing the cups, nothing at all to see. You will need to make the nail setup to do the effect as seen in the preview. This isn't a gimmick, per say, but is vital to doing it with a nail. Wether or not you have this nail setup with you or not, however, doesn't matter. The methodology can be used with any Styrofoam cups anytime, anywhere.

Safety: Instinct is about as safe as roulette routines come. There is only 1 thing that could make this effect at all risky but that is almost entirely under your control. I feel very comfortable in performing this routine and believe you will to, after playing with presentation this becomes as close to %100 safe as it can be. Understand, though, that NO routine of this nature is completely safe and does rely on your performing skills to ensure your own safety.

Bonus Routines: Matthew also teaches several bonus routines and ideas for Instinct. Several of which are ways of using the basic method behind the roulette but applying it in another effect. These bonus routines are also for those that don't wish to perform the roulette for possible safety concerns (see safety info above). He also teaches "Impulse" which is a Truth Teller/Liar routine that has nothing to do with Instinct, but shares a common feel in methodology. This is a cool routine but probably not something you would put in your act. It is, however, totally impromptu so it could make for a good spur of the moment mentalism piece.


Final Thoughts: All in all I could not be happier with Instinct. The method is direct, diabolical, and stupidly simple. This is a piece that merits allot of thought in performance and, with the right presentation, can bring the house down. This has gone straight into my act and could make a great piece in yours.


Thanks,
C
 
Aug 31, 2007
467
1
Canada
"There is only 1 thing that could make this effect at all risky but that is almost entirely under your control."

This worrys me. What do you mean almost? I can accept risk that is entirely based on the performer's error, but if there is something in the method/handling that is a risk and you can't control 100% of the time, so long as YOU don't make an error, I would be concerned.
 
Aug 31, 2007
106
0
36
C=B...Glad you liked it. Your right about the timing being done before the whole HD thing got big. We now shoot all of our DVD's with an HD camera. Either way, it's the effect/method that counts and I am glad that you enjoyed it and found it clever.

Glenn West...there is only one thing that can make the effect go bad. But, it's only if you don't follow what I say on the DVD. It isn't anything difficult, just something to be aware of when performing.

Matthew Mello
 
C=B...Glad you liked it. Your right about the timing being done before the whole HD thing got big. We now shoot all of our DVD's with an HD camera. Either way, it's the effect/method that counts and I am glad that you enjoyed it and found it clever.

Glenn West...there is only one thing that can make the effect go bad. But, it's only if you don't follow what I say on the DVD. It isn't anything difficult, just something to be aware of when performing.

Matthew Mello

Certainly man. Great effect.

Glenn, look at it this way. If spectators switch cards during a multiple selection routine you could be in trouble. Same idea here. You need to be sure of your performing and spectator management but the setup does most of the work for you. I say this is not completely safe because look at the nature of the effect, its a roulette. There is a element of danger when dealing with this type of effect no matter what.

C
 
Aug 31, 2007
467
1
Canada
Certainly man. Great effect.

Glenn, look at it this way. If spectators switch cards during a multiple selection routine you could be in trouble. Same idea here. You need to be sure of your performing and spectator management but the setup does most of the work for you. I say this is not completely safe because look at the nature of the effect, its a roulette. There is a element of danger when dealing with this type of effect no matter what.

C


Yeah, that's not a reassuring way to put it at all man.

Mixing up spectator's cards, and mixing up which cup has a nail are two VERY different mess ups.

Are you saying the spectators are able to do something that could mess you up?

I would not leave this in the hands of the specs following my instructions. If there is a possibility of error, i want it to be entirely my error to make.

And, no, I do not consider mis-communication with the specs an error worth the risk.
 
Sep 1, 2007
185
1
Yeah, that's not a reassuring way to put it at all man.

Mixing up spectator's cards, and mixing up which cup has a nail are two VERY different mess ups.

Are you saying the spectators are able to do something that could mess you up?

I would not leave this in the hands of the specs following my instructions. If there is a possibility of error, i want it to be entirely my error to make.

And, no, I do not consider mis-communication with the specs an error worth the risk.

Glenn,

The way this effect is designed, if the spec tried to mess you up you would know it. I can't say much more without exposing, but you would know if the spec did anything other then what you instructed, immediately. It is just one of the safety features Matthew built into this effect.

Please feel free to PM me for further discussion on this.

Brian Rodgers
 
Exactly.

What I am trying to get across is that it is impossible for this routine or any like it to be truly 100 percent safe. There is a nail involved, there is danger involved in the effect, period. Like there are cards in a card trick there is danger in this type of magic. But that is the whole reason to do this type of magic anyhow.

No, it is not miscommunication or incorrect following of instructions that would mess up the routine. However, if a spectator wants to screw with you, it is in fact possible. But like Brian said, if they do you will undoubtably know it. And also, with this being a "danger" effect, the chances of a spectator wanting you to get hurt in the first place is pretty much nil.

C
 
Aug 31, 2007
467
1
Canada
Thanks for clearing that up.

I would just want any possible risk to only be there by my own fualt, or error, not through minor chance, or something someone else did.
 
Aug 31, 2007
106
0
36
Right, I completely agree. When designing the effect I wanted to make sure it was as safe as possible. The only way that this will mess up is if the spectator goes out of their way to mess with you. And if they do, then you'll know that they have immediately and you can stop the effect.

I don't want to go into to much detail, but you will be able to tell.

All in all, I've been performing this for 6 years and I've never had a spectator try and mess it up. I've never had to stop a performance because the spectator changed something.

Matthew Mello

Thanks for clearing that up.

I would just want any possible risk to only be there by my own fualt, or error, not through minor chance, or something someone else did.
 
Dec 17, 2007
858
2
Canada
Right, I completely agree. When designing the effect I wanted to make sure it was as safe as possible. The only way that this will mess up is if the spectator goes out of their way to mess with you. And if they do, then you'll know that they have immediately and you can stop the effect.

I don't want to go into to much detail, but you will be able to tell.

All in all, I've been performing this for 6 years and I've never had a spectator try and mess it up. I've never had to stop a performance because the spectator changed something.

Matthew Mello

I want to buy this but is the download Mac compatible?


-Michael


EDIT 600 posts w00t!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Searching...
0 Results