This is a routine I do as well. I always loved SAW and the LifeSaver version but the way Fields suggests to do it never quite worked for me. I saw Dan use a mint (instead of those sticky-as-hell candies Sean recommends) and thought it was brilliant. Dan, hope you don't mind I use that idea, haha (I perform it completely differently, just use the idea of the lifesaver and dental floss)
However, when I perform it I usually try to appear to swallow the mint whole. As said, its just artistic difference. For me it seems more like a physical stunt when I swallow a whole lifesaver and pull it through the throat whole. For me, chewing it up makes it seem more like a trick. Again, its just artistic opinion.
At the same time, however, when Dan does it I think it is just brilliant and the chewing is justified. Why? I have no earthly idea. Its just the difference between artists, for him it just works.
And by the way, as much as I love doing this routine it is even more fun to WATCH. When I saw this live I was sitting in a group of laymen. When Dan sawed into his neck everyone looked like they had just seen a car wreck. I sat and laughed hysterically.
I know this post is turning into an epitaph, but I just have to share something.
I did my lifesaver routine last weekend at a gig. The performance was a total cluster eff to begin with. We got called on stage 30-45 minutes EARLY with about 2 minutes to setup. I went on stage and had no microphone, no music, nothing(the people behind the gig didn't speak english very well and didn't understand the phrase "I need a microphone").
I starting doing the routine and everything was great until the end. Apparently I "sawed" to deeply into my neck and when I went to pull out the floss got stuck, the lifesaver flew OFF OF THE FLOSS and then I ripped the last of the floss through my neck. The crowd was grossed out and ate it up, but it hurt like no tomorrow. However, what really stung was when I tried to sanitize my neck with an alcohol pad. My god.
C