SNC 3rd week the real winner gets screwed.

U

Ulysses

Guest
I don't know what the malfunction of the T11 judges is, I just know that for the last 3 weeks the wrong person clearly and without question won.

Notice how the winner of the last 3 weeks have had 1 post? This latest winner had a total of 9 post made since this time last year. 8 of those 9 were SNC entries.

People who aren't active posters are winning these things, and is that right to everyone else who actual participates?

I think not. T11 should implement a rule that you need to have a certain amount of post before you are eligible to enter a SNC contest. And I am talking about quality post as in more than just "Dude kewl trick!". It's not right to have dedicated yourself to a forum when someone who doesn't give a sh*t about until it comes down to winning "free stuff" enters in and takes it from actual participating members who rightfully deserve it.

Active members should take top priority over people who just sign up to enter in a contest. Most of the active members have more than likely purchased things from T11, these 1 time users enter to win some free things and don't buy jack from this place...yet they're rewarded.

And NO I am not a sore loser who lost a SNC...I didn't even enter the last two. I am writing this because this is an area for concern and it's flawed and It needs to be addressed.
 
W

WitchDocIsIn

Elite Member
Sep 13, 2008
5,888
2,947
You bring up some very valid points.

However, they are somewhat reduced by the fact that you're posting as a guest and you put it in the completely wrong forum. In the General Discussion forum there is a stickied thread specifically for SNC issues.

I don't think I agree with the idea of having a minimum post count to enter a contest. A magician is a magician and people should be judged on the merit of their entry, not the number of posts. Some people just have nothing to say, but that doesn't make them not a magician. And there's no way to know if the people who aren't posting much have bought stuff from T11. Nor is there anything that says those who've posted a lot have purchased more than those who haven't.

Now, I've disagreed with who won before, but that's not my call. T11 puts on the contests, they decide who wins. Personally, I'd prefer they not look at the name of the poster at all, and just look at the entry to the contest.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Searching...
{[{ searchResultsCount }]} Results