I'd get TORN, definitely.
The setup for TNR is annoying and long. TORN is quick, almost impromptu (like a 30 second setup), and effective.
I mean, what's the point in restoring a card that's different? Surely the whole idea of a torn and restored is that you take their selection, rip it, and restore it. What's the point in it being another card? Think about it from the spectator's point of view. I think the idea of 2 climaxes didn't quite work out for TNR.
TORN, by far.