Tally-Hos, no doubt. They are much better. The brown Wynns don't fan well, especially after a while, and because of the jumbo indexes they look terrible when you fan them or spread them for a spectator to choose. The colors are also darker, while Tallys have nice full colors. The only reason to get Wynns (brown) may be because you are curious what they fee like or foolish enough to give in to the hype that they are very rare (like 7000 decks or so).