i don't have this effect, but its chapstick guys, as long as its the same kind as someone else has, which i would think is pretty common, just sleeve their chapstick and do the effect and switch it out when giving it back, its a small item and sleeving would be soooo easy. that would make it seem like the "true miracle" that you guys are expecting, is biten coin done with a normal coin? no of course not, thats what separates the noobs from people who want to perform magic and take the extra time to make it that much better. its not the tricks you do, any one trick usually does not take a while to learn to get it down, but its going from one effect to another and switching in and out gaffs and gimmicks thats what separates the men from the boys i feel.